How to Set Up a Thanksgiving Coffee Bar (Plus Pie and Coffee Pairings)

Updated on  
How to Set Up a Thanksgiving Coffee Bar (Plus Pie and Coffee Pairings)

The turkey gets all the attention. But ask anyone who's hosted Thanksgiving, and they'll tell you the after-dinner coffee is when everyone finally relaxes.

A coffee bar keeps that moment easy. Guests serve themselves, you stay out of the kitchen, and everyone gets the cup they actually want.

Step 1: Pick three coffees

Three is the sweet spot: enough choice to feel special, not so much that you're brewing all night.

Label each carafe so nobody gets a surprise at 10 p.m.

Step 2: Set out the extras

You don't need a lot. A few small bowls and pitchers go a long way:

  • Cream, half-and-half and a dairy-free milk
  • Sugar, brown sugar and a sweetener
  • Cinnamon and nutmeg for sprinkling
  • Whipped cream, if you're feeling generous
  • A stack of mugs and a few spoons

Step 3: Make it easy to find

Set the coffee bar away from the main kitchen traffic, like a sideboard or a corner of the counter. Put the mugs on one end and the toppings on the other so people move through it in one direction.

If you'd like to offer espresso too, a Bean-to-Brew makes a 2 oz shot with one button, and guests can pull their own.

Pie and coffee pairings

Pie Try it with Why it works
Pumpkin Cinnamon Bun or a medium roast Warm spice meets warm spice
Pecan French Roast A bold cup balances the sweetness
Apple Breakfast Blend Light and easy next to tart fruit
Chocolate cream Swiss Chocolate or French Roast Chocolate on chocolate, or dark against sweet
Sweet potato Toasted Southern Pecan Nutty and cozy together

There are no wrong answers here. These are just good places to start.

One last tip

Brew a fresh pot right before dessert instead of keeping one warm all afternoon. Coffee that sits on a hot plate for hours starts to taste flat.

Happy Thanksgiving from our family to yours.

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.